Procedure Volume Patient Data Patient Conditions Reviews General Payments Back to Top

Home > PA Providers > Sports Medicine Doctors

Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO

Accepting New Patients

(65 Ratings)

Specializes in: Sports Medicine and Family Medicine

Lake Erie College of Osteopathic Medicine (2013)

1227 BALTIMORE STREET
HANOVER, PA 17331

(717) 812-5190

Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO is a sports medicine doctor in HANOVER, PA specializing in sports medicine and family medicine. He graduated from Lake Erie College of Osteopathic Medicine in 2013 and has 12 years of experience. Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO is affiliated with WellSpan Health, WellSpan Gettysburg Hospital and WellSpan Medical Group.

Office Locations

1227 BALTIMORE STREET
HANOVER, PA 17331

open_in_new

Noteworthy Medicare Patient Procedures Performed by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO in 2023

Click on any procedure below to see further details on volume and pricing among Medicare patients.

Top 25%

By Volume:

flu shot

In 2013, Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO performed more flu shot procedures for Medicare patients than 75% of providers in related specialties within Pennsylvania.

Medicare Procedure and Patient Information

2017 Medicare Procedure Volume

The top procedures that Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO treated as a sports medicine doctor in HANOVER, PA during 2017 were X-rays, thoracic (chest) imaging, lab tests and blood draw.

Volume of procedures performed by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO for Medicare patients.

blood draw	31
doctor visit	123
lab tests	70
thoracic (chest) imaging	74
X-rays	74

2017 Medicare Patient Data

Information about Medicare patients treated by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO.

**Gender**
Male	67
Female	142

**Ethnicity**
Non-Hispanic White	170
Black	28
Hispanic	0
Asian	0
Other	0
Native American	0

**Age**
From 65 to 74	108
From 75 to 84	49
85 and over	22
Less than 65	30

Conditions of Medicare patients treated by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO in 2017

The most common conditions of Medicare patients that Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO treated during 2017 were hypertension, high cholesterol, diabetes and ischemic heart disease.

Hypertension	60
High Cholesterol	47
Stroke	6
Ischemic Heart Disease	27
Depression	26
Chronic Kidney Disease	22
Asthma	9
Osteoperosis	7
Atrial Fibrilation	11
Heart Failure	11
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease	16
Diabetes	29
Dementia	10
Cancer	9

Medicare Procedure and Patient Information

2018 Medicare Procedure Volume

The top procedures that Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO treated as a sports medicine doctor in HANOVER, PA during 2018 were lab tests, blood draw, X-rays and breathing treatment.

Volume of procedures performed by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO for Medicare patients.

abdominal imaging	16
blood draw	101
breathing treatment	34
doctor visit	427
lab tests	330
thoracic (chest) imaging	26
X-rays	42

2018 Medicare Patient Data

Information about Medicare patients treated by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO.

**Gender**
Male	224
Female	355

**Ethnicity**
Non-Hispanic White	449
Black	93
Hispanic	0
Asian	0
Other	15
Native American	0

**Age**
From 65 to 74	288
From 75 to 84	149
85 and over	66
Less than 65	76

Conditions of Medicare patients treated by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO in 2018

The most common conditions of Medicare patients that Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO treated during 2018 were hypertension, high cholesterol, ischemic heart disease and diabetes.

Hypertension	70
High Cholesterol	63
Stroke	5
Ischemic Heart Disease	33
Depression	27
Chronic Kidney Disease	27
Asthma	9
Osteoperosis	7
Atrial Fibrilation	11
Heart Failure	15
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease	17
Diabetes	30
Dementia	8
Cancer	9

Medicare Procedure and Patient Information

2019 Medicare Procedure Volume

The top procedures that Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO treated as a sports medicine doctor in HANOVER, PA during 2019 were preventive care and vaccines.

Volume of procedures performed by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO for Medicare patients.

doctor visit	239
preventive care	20
vaccines	20

2019 Medicare Patient Data

Information about Medicare patients treated by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO.

**Gender**
Male	73
Female	79

**Age**
From 65 to 74	69
From 75 to 84	45
85 and over	11
Less than 65	27

Conditions of Medicare patients treated by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO in 2019

The most common conditions of Medicare patients that Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO treated during 2019 were hypertension, high cholesterol, chronic kidney disease and ischemic heart disease.

Hypertension	66
High Cholesterol	64
Stroke	0
Ischemic Heart Disease	36
Depression	32
Chronic Kidney Disease	39
Asthma	9
Osteoperosis	0
Atrial Fibrilation	8
Heart Failure	18
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease	15
Diabetes	34
Dementia	0
Cancer	10

Medicare Procedure and Patient Information

2020 Medicare Procedure Volume

The top procedures that Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO treated as a sports medicine doctor in HANOVER, PA during 2020 were preventive care and vaccines.

Volume of procedures performed by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO for Medicare patients.

doctor visit	363
preventive care	53
vaccines	53

2020 Medicare Patient Data

Information about Medicare patients treated by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO.

**Gender**
Male	115
Female	86

**Ethnicity**
Non-Hispanic White	188
Black	0
Hispanic	0
Asian	0
Other	0
Native American	0

**Age**
From 65 to 74	100
From 75 to 84	59
85 and over	21
Less than 65	21

Conditions of Medicare patients treated by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO in 2020

The most common conditions of Medicare patients that Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO treated during 2020 were high cholesterol, hypertension, chronic kidney disease and ischemic heart disease.

Hypertension	67
High Cholesterol	75
Stroke	0
Ischemic Heart Disease	37
Depression	24
Chronic Kidney Disease	47
Asthma	7
Osteoperosis	7
Atrial Fibrilation	15
Heart Failure	17
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease	13
Diabetes	30
Dementia	7
Cancer	9

Medicare Procedure and Patient Information

2021 Medicare Procedure Volume

The top procedures that Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO treated as a sports medicine doctor in HANOVER, PA during 2021 were preventive care and vaccines.

Volume of procedures performed by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO for Medicare patients.

doctor visit	451
preventive care	78
vaccines	78

2021 Medicare Patient Data

Information about Medicare patients treated by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO.

**Gender**
Male	156
Female	122

**Ethnicity**
Non-Hispanic White	261
Black	0
Hispanic	0
Asian	0
Other	0
Native American	0

**Age**
From 65 to 74	144
From 75 to 84	78
85 and over	25
Less than 65	31

Conditions of Medicare patients treated by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO in 2021

The most common conditions of Medicare patients that Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO treated during 2021 were hypertension, high cholesterol, chronic kidney disease and ischemic heart disease.

Hypertension	74
High Cholesterol	71
Stroke	4
Ischemic Heart Disease	35
Depression	28
Chronic Kidney Disease	59
Asthma	8
Osteoperosis	6
Atrial Fibrilation	13
Heart Failure	13
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease	14
Diabetes	28
Dementia	8
Cancer	9

Medicare Procedure and Patient Information

2022 Medicare Procedure Volume

The top procedures that Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO treated as a sports medicine doctor in HANOVER, PA during 2022 were preventive care and vaccines.

Volume of procedures performed by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO for Medicare patients.

doctor visit	447
preventive care	131
vaccines	131

2022 Medicare Patient Data

Information about Medicare patients treated by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO.

**Gender**
Male	163
Female	151

**Ethnicity**
Non-Hispanic White	296
Black	0
Hispanic	0
Asian	0
Other	0
Native American	0

**Age**
From 65 to 74	164
From 75 to 84	93
85 and over	26
Less than 65	31

Conditions of Medicare patients treated by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO in 2022

The most common conditions of Medicare patients that Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO treated during 2022 were high cholesterol, hypertension, chronic kidney disease and diabetes.

Hypertension	75
High Cholesterol	75
Stroke	10
Ischemic Heart Disease	32
Depression	27
Chronic Kidney Disease	46
Asthma	10
Osteoperosis	10
Atrial Fibrilation	22
Heart Failure	14
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease	16
Diabetes	35
Dementia	8
Cancer	12

Medicare Procedure and Patient Information

2023 Medicare Procedure Volume

The top procedures that Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO treated as a sports medicine doctor in HANOVER, PA during 2023 were preventive care and vaccines.

Volume of procedures performed by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO for Medicare patients.

doctor visit	387
preventive care	48
vaccines	48

2023 Medicare Patient Data

Information about Medicare patients treated by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO.

**Gender**
Male	144
Female	124

**Ethnicity**
Non-Hispanic White	251
Black	0
Hispanic	0
Asian	0
Other	0
Native American	0

**Age**
From 65 to 74	133
From 75 to 84	91
85 and over	24
Less than 65	20

Conditions of Medicare patients treated by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO in 2023

The most common conditions of Medicare patients that Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO treated during 2023 were high cholesterol, hypertension, chronic kidney disease and ischemic heart disease.

Hypertension	75
High Cholesterol	75
Stroke	8
Ischemic Heart Disease	35
Depression	25
Chronic Kidney Disease	43
Asthma	12
Osteoperosis	10
Atrial Fibrilation	21
Heart Failure	15
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease	16
Diabetes	32
Dementia	6
Cancer	15

Medicare Procedure and Patient Information

Average Medicare Procedure Volume From 2017 - 2023

Volume of procedures performed by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO for Medicare patients.

The highest averages for the top procedures that Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO treated as a sports medicine doctor in HANOVER, PA were lab tests, preventive care, vaccines and blood draw.

abdominal imaging	16
blood draw	66
doctor visit	348
lab tests	200
preventive care	66
thoracic (chest) imaging	50
vaccines	66
X-rays	58

Average Medicare Patient Data From 2017 - 2023

Information about Medicare patients treated by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO.

**Gender**
Male	134
Female	151

**Ethnicity**
Black / African American	17
Asian / Pacific Islander	0
Non-Hispanic White	230
Hispanic	0
Native American / Alaskan Native	0
Other	2

**Age**
75 to 84	80
85 and over	27
Less than 65	33
65 to 74	143

Average of Total of Conditions of Medicare patients treated by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO From 2017 - 2023

The highest averages of the most common conditions of Medicare patients that Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO treated were hypertension, high cholesterol, chronic kidney disease and ischemic heart disease.

Hypertension	69
High Cholesterol	67
Stroke	4
Ischemic Heart Disease	33
Depression	27
Chronic Kidney Disease	40
Asthma	9
Osteoporosis	6
Heart Failure	14
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease	15
Diabetes	31
Atrial Fibrillation	14
Dementia	6
Cancer	10

Education & Training

Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO graduated from Lake Erie College of Osteopathic Medicine in 2013. He completed residency at University of Pittsburgh Medical Center (UPMC). He is certified by the American Osteopathic Board of Family Physicians | Family Medicine/OMT and has a state license in Maryland.

Medical School: Lake Erie College of Osteopathic Medicine (2013)

Residency: University of Pittsburgh Medical Center (UPMC) (2016)

Board Certification: American Osteopathic Board of Family Physicians | Family Medicine/OMT

Licensed In: Maryland

Affiliations & Hospitals

Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO is associated with these hospitals and organizations:

WellSpan Health

WellSpan Gettysburg Hospital

WellSpan Medical Group

Insurance Information

Please note: Insurance information may change at any time, and the provider may accept your insurance plan even if it is not listed below. Please contact the provider's office to confirm that your insurance is accepted.

Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO appears to accept the following insurance providers: Centene, United Healthcare, Medicare, Medicaid, Highmark Wholecare (formerly Gateway), Preferred Health Care, Johns Hopkins Health Care, Jefferson Health Plans (formerly HPP) and WellSpan Population Health (formerly SCP).

Insurance Accepted by Provider includes:

According to our sources, Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO accepts the following insurance providers:

Centene

United Healthcare

Medicare

Medicaid

Highmark Wholecare (formerly Gateway)

Preferred Health Care

Johns Hopkins Health Care

Jefferson Health Plans (formerly HPP)

WellSpan Population Health (formerly SCP)

Ratings & Reviews

Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO has an exceptional overall rating with an average of 4.83 out of 5 stars based on 65 ratings. We collect ratings and reviews of Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO from all over the web to help you find the right in HANOVER, PA.

4.83

Overall Rating

(65 Ratings)

Leave a Review

Reviews From Around The Web

Overall Rating: 5.0 2025-09-28

Patient verified via Press Ganey

I routinely recommend Dr. McCarl to family and friends looking for a new provider

General Payments

These charts describe general payments received by Dr. Matthew James McCarl, DO. Doctors may receive payments for a number of reasons, including meal compensation, travel compensation, and consulting.

**Payments by Company**
Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc	$40 XARELTO $40
Sunovion Pharmaceuticals Inc.	$18 LATUDA $18
Mayne Pharma Inc.	$16 DORYX $16

**Types of Payments**
Food and Beverage	$74

Biography

Dr. Matthew McCarl specializes in family medicine and sports medicine and practices in Hanover, PA. Patient reviews placed Dr. McCarl at an average of 5.0 stars (out of 5). He appears to be in-network for Centene, Medicaid, and Medicare, in addition to other insurance carriers. He attended Lake Erie College of Osteopathic Medicine for medical school and subsequently trained at the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center (UPMC) for residency. He is professionally affiliated with WellSpan Medical Group and WellSpan Gettysburg Hospital. Doctor.com reports that he is accepting new patients at his office in Hanover, PA.